Which deck box for Magic? A format-by-format guide
Search for "a Magic deck box" and you hit a paradox right away: the same game is played with 40, 60 or 100 cards depending on the format. A box that is perfect for a Standard deck can be too tight for Commander, and a box that is too roomy lets your cards slide around. This guide sorts it out, format by format, and points you to our dedicated articles when you want to dig deeper.
Short answer: for Magic, pick a deck box sized for double sleeves. For Constructed (Standard, Pioneer, Modern, Legacy, Pauper), plan for 75 cards: 60 in the deck and 15 in the sideboard. For Commander, plan for 100 cards plus tokens. A capacity of 125 double-sleeved cards covers both.
What matters in every format
Capacity, measured double-sleeved
Many capacities are quoted with single sleeves, or even unsleeved. Yet a deck you actually play is usually double-sleeved, which makes every card thicker. The right habit: start from your real card count, sleeves included, and keep room for tokens, a die or your decklist. Our double sleeving guide walks through the method, and the deck box dimensions guide gives you the measurements to compare.
The closure
In a tournament bag, a box that pops open on its own means 75 cards scattered everywhere. A snap-fit closure holds without magnets and stays shut under the pressure of a packed bag. We explain how in our article on snap-fit closures.
Everything that travels with the deck
Tokens, emblems, dice, a life counter: a Magic deck never travels alone. The more tokens a format generates, the more that extra room matters.
Format by format: what you need to store
Standard and Pioneer
A 60-card minimum deck and a sideboard of up to 15. Standard rotates every year, Pioneer does not: either way, the box stays with you longer than the deck inside it. See our Standard article and our Pioneer article.
Modern and Legacy
Same deckbuilding rule, 60 plus 15, but these decks often represent years of collecting and cards you could not easily replace. Protection comes first here: double sleeves, a rigid box, a reliable closure. The details are in our Modern article and our Legacy article.
Pauper
Commons only, but the same 60 plus 15 and the same care: a well-tuned Pauper deck is, above all, hours of deckbuilding. Read our Pauper article.
Limited: draft and sealed
A 40-card minimum deck built on the spot, plus the rest of your pool. The need is different: leaving the event with every card neatly stored. Our prerelease checklist helps you prepare for the day.
Commander
Exactly 100 cards, commander included, one copy of each. Add the tokens, often plenty of them, and you get the most demanding format in terms of volume. A "100-card" box is almost always too tight once you double sleeve. We cover it in a full article.
The quick reference
| Format | Deck | On top | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard | 60 minimum | Sideboard up to 15 | Yearly rotation |
| Pioneer | 60 minimum | Sideboard up to 15 | No rotation |
| Modern | 60 minimum | Sideboard up to 15 | Valuable cards |
| Legacy | 60 minimum | Sideboard up to 15 | Hard-to-replace cards |
| Pauper | 60 minimum | Sideboard up to 15 | Commons only |
| Limited | 40 minimum | The rest of your pool | Storage after the event |
| Commander | Exactly 100 | Tokens, counters | The bulkiest format |
One box per deck, or one box for all?
Plenty of players switch between formats. Two approaches compete: a dedicated box for each deck, recognizable at a glance, or a Proteus whose magnetic panels and medallions you swap to match tonight's deck. Our comparison one box per deck or Proteus helps you decide, and if your collection keeps growing, see how to organize several Commander decks.
What our deck boxes offer Magic players
One single capacity, designed to cover every format: up to 125 double-sleeved standard cards, with an interior volume of 76 × 68 × 98 mm. Enough for a Constructed deck with its sideboard and tokens, or a complete Commander deck. Ultra Pro, Dragon Shield, KMC, Gamegenic and most standard sleeves fit, double sleeves included.
Every box is 3D printed in premium PLA, then hand-painted with our Inksmith finish: reliefs brought out by drybrushing, a weathered, vintage look, and no two boxes exactly alike. Dragon, pirate, or a blank canvas with your own artwork: the theme is yours, and lid engraving is available as an option.
Frequently asked questions
What size deck box do I need for a Magic deck?
For Constructed, plan for 75 double-sleeved cards: a 60-card deck plus a 15-card sideboard, along with tokens. For Commander, plan for 100 double-sleeved cards and room for tokens. A capacity of 125 double-sleeved cards covers both.
Is a 100-card deck box enough for Commander?
Rarely. Advertised capacities are often measured with single sleeves. Double-sleeved, a 100-card deck plus tokens quickly outgrows what a "100-card" box can hold.
Do I need a different deck box for each format?
No. A box that holds 125 double-sleeved cards fits a Constructed deck with its sideboard just as well as a full Commander deck. The real choice is between one box per deck and a modular box you adapt to tonight's deck.
Design your Magic deck box
Standard, Modern or Commander: build the box for your deck in the Forge with a live preview, starting at €27. Made in France in our workshop and closed with a snap-fit, every box is photographed before it ships.
Keep exploring:
- Discover the custom MTG deck box, compatible with your Magic cards in every format.
- Explore the Commander deck box for your 100-card decks.
- Read player reviews: over 1,500 sales and a 4.9/5 rating from 319 verified Etsy reviews.